Montgomery Catholic Preparatory School's elementary campuses participated in the FBI Safe Online Surfing program. Each month the FBI recognizes the top school in the nation for one of three categories. Montgomery Catholic's Holy Spirit campus won the starfish category for the month of November 2015, which means the campus received the highest score in the program in the country.
On honors day held on January 14, 2016, Montgomery Catholic president Mrs. Anne Ceasar accepted the Award for the Holy Spirit campus from the FBI for winning the nationwide FBI-Safe Online Searching competition - Starfish category for November 2015 with an overall score of 97 percent. FBI Special Agent Greg Holston was on campus to present a special certificate to the school. Each student received a certificate from their technology teacher, Mrs. Debbie Mayer for their efforts in helping the school achieve the top score.